Skip to content
The Podcast
Pitching Society
Book a call

Choosing an agency

How do you choose a podcast booking agency?

The short answer

Choose the agency that starts with your business goal, books you on shows your buyers already listen to, preps you for your interviews, and keeps each episode working after it airs. Then ask how they'll prove it.

What should a podcast booking agency do for you?

A good agency gets you booked on right-fit podcasts and helps each interview turn into business. The booking is where the work starts.

Most experts come to us after trying a PR firm, a virtual assistant, or doing it themselves. They got booked. Some got booked a lot. Nothing happened, because there was no system behind the bookings.

What questions should you ask before you hire one?

Ask these seven before you sign anything.

  1. What do you want to happen in my business? A good agency asks about your goals first. Clients, contracts, speaking, book sales. Every booking should point back to that.
  2. How do you choose the shows? Listen for your buyer. The right show is the one your buyers listen to, even if it's smaller.
  3. Will you help me with my message first? Anyone who's confused will not buy. If your message isn't clear, more interviews just spread the confusion.
  4. Who preps me before my interviews? Prep is where a good interview becomes a great one.
  5. What happens after the episode airs? Ask about transcripts, clips, articles, and getting your name across the web.
  6. How will I know what I got? Ask what they report each month, and how it ties to your goal.
  7. What do you guarantee? Get it in writing.

What are the red flags when hiring a podcast booking agency?

The biggest red flag is an agency that only talks about how many shows you'll get. Volume alone is a vanity number.

Watch for these too.

  • They'll book any show that says yes.
  • They can't tell you who a show's listeners are.
  • There's no prep. You're on your own once the interview is booked.
  • There's no plan for after the episode. It airs, and that's it.
  • They can't tell you what a booking did for your business.

Should you hire an agency or a virtual assistant?

Hire an agency if you want strategy and don't have hours to manage someone. A virtual assistant can send pitches, and you'll be the one deciding where they go and what they say.

Experts tell us all the time that they ended up micromanaging an assistant just to land quality shows. That time costs you too.

How is The Podcast Pitching Society different?

We build authority, with podcast guesting at the center. Every engagement starts with your message and ties each conversation to something you can measure. A booked call, a signed contract, a paid stage, a citation that keeps working.

  • We start with your message. Month one sharpens it before we pitch.
  • We book every client on three or more shows every month they work with us.
  • We guarantee at least 18 bookings in six months on The Citable Expert™ Engine.
  • You prep with me before your interviews.
  • We keep working after the episode airs, so it shows up where buyers and AI tools look.

Our sales calls are decision calls. You'll leave with a customized action plan and a straight answer on fit.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a podcast booking contract be?

Long enough to say the same thing many times. Ours run six months, because authority compounds. If you want to test it first, The Citable Expert™ Accelerator is a six-week trial.

What's the difference between a podcast booking agency and a PR firm?

A PR firm often covers many kinds of media, like press and TV. A podcast booking agency focuses on getting you booked as a podcast guest.

How much should I pay a podcast booking agency?

Most charge $500 to $8,000 a month, depending on how much they do. See how much a podcast booking agency costs for the full breakdown.

Work with us

Want an agency that shows its work?

Book a decision call with me. Bring your questions, all seven of them. You'll get straight answers and a customized action plan.